My Child Matters:Palliative Care for children with cancer in Bangladesh |
Afzal H. Choudhury |
ASHIC - Foundation for children cancer, Dhaka, India |
The
ASHIC Palliative Care Unit (PCU) was started in 2006 sponsored by UICC and
Sanofi-Aventis, under this MCM program. ASHIC takes the opportunity to offer its
thanks to the UICC and Sanofi-Aventis steering committee for selecting this
project.
Without
the funding of EURO 60,000.00 from MCM, the ASHIC PCU project would have
remained in cold storage for a longer period or possibly would never be
implemented.
Before
the start of the MCM program, ASHIC had no significant exposition to
international funding and was inexperienced with regard to various problems,
which were sometimes very frustrating. However, Geoff Thaxter (at that time Vice
Chair of ICCCPO) was constantly guiding ASHIC through email and phone calls, on
how to overcome the problems and manage the situations in difficult times. The
ASHIC Foundation is extremely grateful to Geoff Thaxter for his support and
encouragement, which has allowed ASHIC to bring the project to the present
status.
How
do we perceive Palliative Care?
Terminally
ill patients who fail to respond to curative treatment go through a period of
unrelenting pain and agony in their remaining days or months. Through pain and
symptom management palliative care aims at making the last days of the patients
as comfortable and painless as possible as well as providing moral and spiritual
supports to their near ones.
It
is needed by most children with cancer in Bangladesh
Of
the estimated 6000 to 7000 cancer affected children per year in Bangladesh, a
maximum of 10% gets hospital treatment. The survival rate of most of the
patients who are treated in hospital, is very poor due to a host of factors like
delayed diagnosis, financial difficulties, lack of front line professionals etc.
There is no organized palliative care offered to the unfortunate children. As a
result, there are many cancer affected children in terminal stages, those who
pass their last days in extreme agony.
In
the year 2000, we started a project, called “Shelter”. It is a 20 bed free
accommodation near the Bangladesh Sheikh Mujib Medical University (BSMMU), the
most recognized institution for paediatric oncology treatment in Bangladesh. So
far, more than 170 children received the advantage of the “Shelter”. During
their years long treatments these children had to come and stay in the Shelter
many times. Thus we have specific data about them. According to our records only
19 children survived. Now, imagine their last days in a community where the
family becomes isolated as their neighbors still believe that cancer is an
infectious disease. With respect to this situation we felt that palliative care
is a critical component for children with cancer in Bangladesh.
Setting
up the Palliative Care Unit
The
ASHIC Palliative Care Unit started in May 2006. It is a twelve bed all free
facility (6 for patients and 6 for guardians), run by 4 doctors, 4 nurses, 4
social workers and 2 nurses aid plus a number of volunteers.
The
facility is taking care of the terminally ill patients for a period of 5-10 days
in first admission. During this period, while taking care of the child, parents
are encouraged to participate with doctors and nurses in caring activities.
Along with it, the social workers take the opportunity to counsel the parents on
spiritual and other issues. This approach is taken in order to offer first hand
training to parents on how to take care of the child while at home and to get
them prepared for the worst. After such training, the patient and family are
transported to their home.
Our
social worker who accompanies the family organizes a local community gathering
to inform them about the family and to motivate the community to support them in
a situation where human support is more important then medical care.
After
the children are settled at their homes, they are constantly monitored and
supported by the PCU through phone calls and home visits.
Social
workers are also regularly visiting the families in hospital for counseling the
parents of the in-patient children in order to give an understanding of
Palliative Care and role of the ASHIC PCU. So far, more than 2000 parents and
relatives, in various hospitals were interacted in our counseling activity.
Training
of doctors, nurses and social workers
A
special group of the ASHIC Volunteer Corps (AVC) was organized in December 2006
to support the Foundation’s activities. Among these volunteers are five
oncology specialists, who received training in palliative care abroad. To our
knowledge, there are only twelve such specialists available throughout the
country at present.
Oncologists
from the Volunteer Corps organized training programs for the doctors, nurses and
social workers in order to increase awareness on palliative care. In the past 18
months we have already done six workshops, five seminars, seven training
programs. More than 1500 people have attended.
The
activities are already making a difference
Initially
we had very poor response from families, doctors and hospitals. From the start
in May 2006 to May 2007 we had only 35 patients admitted in the PCU despite all
our efforts. Whereas the intake of patients in the PCU from June to October 2007
(that is the last four months!) has dramatically increased. The total number of
admitted patients (new and re-admissions) has crossed 144 to date.
*
The training for the parents appears to be effective for home care as
families and patients at home are found to be comparatively better settled and
content. As well as the communities appears to be more sympathetic and
supportive.
*
Parents/relatives of the deceased children come to the PCU to express
their gratitude and many of them tell us their tales of gruesome experience, of
their unsuccessful, often year long treatment in hospitals and their financial
trauma. Most of the families praised the role of the PCU and regretted not
having had the benefits for their gone away children earlier.
Hospital
authorities are realizing the need of Palliative Care
The
authorities of Bangladesh Sheikh Mujib Medical University who found it difficult
to accept the concept of palliative care and were not extending support to our
program - despite our long standing support service from the Shelter to children
under treatment in BSMMU - has opened a palliative care unit in the hospital
under the leadership of Prof. Dr. Nizamuddin in October 2007. Dr. Nizamuddin in
his opening speech frankly admitted that doctors in Bangladesh were not aware
about the concept of palliative care until recently. We came to know that the
National Institute of Cancer Research and Hospital is also opening a palliative
care unit soon. We consider this to be a significant mile stone of our campaign.
Slowly
people are showing interest to be a member of the AVC (ASHIC Volunteer Corps). A
chapter of AVC in Sylhet, another district town 200 km from Dhaka, is in the
process of formation. We are organizing a training program in Sylhet for 40
participants of doctors and nurses to be selected by AVC members of the Sylhet
chapter. The training will be conducted jointly by the AVC oncologists and
expatriates from the UK arranged by Geoff Thaxter from MCM funding.
The
Dhaka Medical College, the number one medical college and hospital in the
country is also now realizing the importance and appreciates the need for
palliative care. So, we hope it is not far away that palliative care will be
taken up as a national agenda for patients of all ages.
Lessons
learnt
We
believe palliative care is the most important item in countries where medical
facilities are insufficient. But it is felt that this new concept has little
acceptability as doctor’s preference is to focus on patients with hope of
recovery more than on those who no longer respond to treatment even though the
majority of children falls under this category.
ASHIC
is working hard to make the project a success. However, the progress has not
yett been at the anticipated place because of little acceptability of the
palliative care concept both by doctors and the society. Therefore, sufficient
social interest could not be generated for fund raising from local sources and
we see a weakness in the project’s sustainability without assured funding from
international sources for an extended period.
Transportation
of terminally ill children by public transport to their home village is very
difficult and risky. We will need ambulance cars and more ambulatory facilities
for palliative patients.
We
also need:
-
Seminars and workshops
-
media publicity
-
outreach programs on home care and community support
-
access to palliative medicines.
This
can be done with
-
Assured availability of funds and fund raising
-
Government policy to provide better access to palliative medicines which are
restricted to control drug abuse.
-
More volunteer members in the AVC to support ASHIC activities nation wide
-
Regional centers of service and develop community support
-
More media awareness, advocacy and lobbing.
At this point, I would like to mention a few names, who have helped ASHIC to go ahead with the project: Prof. Dr. Tim Eden, Isabel Mortara and Jose Julio Divino of UICC, Caty Forget and Catherine Boniface of Sanofi-Aventis.
ASHIC
appreciates their involvement in the project, and would like to say Thank you.
Afzal
H. Choudhury
ASHIC - Foundation for children cancer, Dhaka, India